Oh, Enough!

By Pejman Yousefzadeh Posted in Comments (27) / Email this page » / Leave a comment »

It's called being a professional, Andrew. It's called calling them as you see them when you are a member of the press while at the same time bearing in mind that you had better have an overwhelmingly fantastically good reason--beyond the "our critics are our friends" line Tony Snow has taken towards the President--to refuse a call to service from the highest ranking elected official in the land. It's called taking a position of great and solemn responsibility without compromising your principles, but rather taking those principles into the public sphere and showing that you are more than a mere critic, that on the contrary, you are someone willing to personally place into effect the change that you are calling for.

I have critiqued George W. Bush and his policies a fair amount recently. But critiquing a President is not an automatic bar to serving in that President's Administration; especially not if that President has promised to listen and to respect the opinions a critic would be willing to give voice to in private counsel. I assume that is the promise he gave to Tony Snow and I would expect no less of an arrangement between any President and any Press Secretary (it's fairly easy to assume that if Tony Snow didn't get this kind of promise and didn't feel comfortable with it, he would have been more than content to work banker's hours while taking much more to the bank as a major media personality than he will as the White House Press Secretary). And here is the puzzlement: Up until now, one of the chief criticisms of the Bush White House was that it lived "in a bubble" and didn't pay attention to its critics. Now it's hiring one of them and what is the response?

Snark?

And that's it?

"Damned if you do, damned if you don't" must be a fun game to play. But it's also a disingenuous one.

« Question and answer time: the Wes Clark thing.Comments (50) | The Party of Death by Ramesh PonnuruComments (12) »
Oh, Enough! 27 Comments (0 topical, 27 editorial, 0 hidden) Post a comment »

and is threatening to recreate the holocaust

there is genocide in sudan

a terrorist attack in egypt

gas prices are going up

iraq newly formed a government

and tony snow once said somethings which did not support the president...

...stop getting noticed at all.  :)

Well put. . . by theBlur

I once worked with a gentleman who was in the Johnson White House press office.  Told me once how hard it was to return to civillian life after that.

Mr. Snow will be a good change to the mediocre performance during the daily briefings.  Ever since they became televised, I felt that you needed someone like a Tony (or, there are others out there) to just look those idiots in the face and say "what?"

The reporters now pontificate for the camera, and previous WH Press Secs were basically PR people, not accustomed to the press environment.  Tony knows press inside and outside, and can give the likes of Gregory a good a$$ spanking when he tries to perform for the camera.

My dream, ole' Gregory gets on his burbon-induced high horse and ole' Tony looks and him and says (in front of the C-SPAN cameras), "hey, bud, ask a sane question or get out of my room."

Dreams

that would be.

Who? by cwilson

Who is this Andrew Sullivan you speak of?

to attract viewers to press conferences.  I intend to watch when I know one's on.  I hope he is as good as he has seemed all these years.

While he's at it, the conferences could use some humor.  For instance, the Press Secretary laughing at the questions.

andrew squared by jr565

that's twice now in one day where I've read a comment from Andrew that clearly shows him jumping the shark. The first was where he blamed police brutality on Bush's torture policies (as described by Andrew Sullivan).

I think his sleep apnea machine must be on the fritz, because he's sounding more moonbattish by the day.



now, if kerry were pres., he'd call an international conference and solve everything lickety-split.



can't wait to see it all the episodes back to back without interruption

good observation by kent miller

And one that occurred to me while reading this recent, rather uncharitable piece on President Bush, by Peggy Noonan.

http://www.opinionjournal.com/columnists/pnoonan/?id=110008260

I thought about the areas in which I agreed or disagreed with the President. I have come to the conclusion that our alignment on taxes and our tactical and strategic interests in the Middle East outweighed my disagreement on other issues.

In response to your observation:



And here is the puzzlement: Up until now, one of the chief criticisms of the Bush White House was that it lived "in a bubble" and didn't pay attention to its critics. Now it's hiring one of them and what is the response?

Snark?

And that's it?



It is doubtful that President Bush would appoint a spokesperson who agrees with his ostensibly free spending style but disagreed with his approach to the war on terror.  This may be an indication that Snow's past comments do not particularly bother the President because his action in regard to spending is less a reflection of his philosophy than a reflection of where he chooses to spend political capital in such grave times.

Snark? And that's it? by spacedog

Just like in poker.

You can only play the cards you actually hold.

Any trial lawyer would laugh at someone calling this job switch some kind of moral compromise. This is just moving from the Red Sox to the Cubs. What's the sin?

I wonder if they post a schedule anywhere.

describing WH reporters walking in the hall and rehearsing their questions outloud, sort of like Oliiver running over a scene from Hamlet in his dressing room.  Must have been some tough questions. A slight stumble over a unrehearsed answer however is proof of irredeemable stupidity.

     You need a man who has worked with and observed at first hand such hopeless and hapless clods.

at about the time his blog turned into a "we cant slap a terrorist because thats torture, and gays should marry" nonstop rant.

The green-eyed monster by AcademicElephant

Sullivan's comments smack of jealousy--look, I agree with Tony on all these things, and no one is asking me to do anything!

Keep trying, Andrew, and maybe you can be Hillary's assistant press secretary for blog affairs.

Do you think by 10ksnooker

That maybe the problem is that the left's carefully constructed bubble mirage isn't?

Good Luck to Tony by The Lager Lad

Dude's got a tough road to hoe.

It's Inevitable by Athenawise

Tony Snow has already been nicknamed "Snow Job." Didn't take long. Heh...

I hope Tony by johnt

insults Helen Thomas, offers to buy David Gregory his next drink, recommends Weight Watchers for Elizabeth Bumiller, and buys Terry Moran a plastic toy brain.  He may stipulate that if you have to read your own question then you can't ask it and it's not worth answering.

In my flack career by jannelsen

I have worked at places where I agreed with:

  • 50 percent of the policies being promoted, but thought it was kind of a cool job and a step toward advancement.
  • 65 percent, but I really liked the boss and there was a cachet attached to the post.
  • 85 percent, but the boss was a friend, and besides, I had no clue of what was really happening.
  • 85 percent, but the boss was such an improvement over the previous management that my support was enthusiastic. And I needed the job.
  • 90 percent. As close to perfect as the real world allows. And I have a window.

So, in a career of politics and PR, I have compromised my principles many times over. But I have also promoted my principles to the best of my ability and advanced, at the margins, the cause of freedom and free markets.

The only people who can get away with insisting on "my way or else" are billionaires, tyrants, or really cute children with indulgent parents.

To those of you on the left taking potshots at Snow for compromising his values, you fit under Category 3. Only not so cute.

 
Redstate Network Login:
(lost password?)


©2008 Eagle Publishing, Inc. All rights reserved. Legal, Copyright, and Terms of Service